What Happens If Your Stock Falls During a Loan?
It depends on the structure you agreed. Under a recourse or margin facility, a fall below an agreed loan-to-value threshold can trigger a margin call requiring you to post more collateral or repay part of the loan. Under a non-recourse facility, the lender bears the price risk below that level, and you can surrender the shares without further personal liability.
What actually happens when the price drops?
What happens depends on the recourse profile written into your facility. Both structures share a starting mechanic: the loan is advanced against a buffer, so the amount lent is a fraction of the share value, leaving headroom for a decline. In a recourse or margin facility, that headroom is monitored against a maintenance threshold; if the holding falls far enough that the loan-to-value ratio breaches the agreed level, the lender issues a margin call requiring you to post additional collateral or repay part of the principal within a defined cure period. In a non-recourse facility, no such call arises. The lender has priced the downside into the original advance rate and bears the price risk below the agreed level. A moderate fall that stays within the buffer changes nothing in either case — interest accrues, the shares remain pledged, and the facility runs as documented. The distinction matters most in a sharp, sustained decline, which is precisely when borrowers discover which structure they chose. Our risk factors page sets out these scenarios in fuller detail.
How does the loan-to-value buffer work?
The loan-to-value ratio is the loan amount expressed as a percentage of the collateral’s market value, and the gap between that figure and one hundred per cent is the buffer protecting the lender. A position advanced conservatively carries a wider buffer and can absorb a larger fall before any threshold is touched; a more aggressive advance leaves less room. The buffer is not arbitrary — it is calibrated to the volatility, liquidity and concentration of the specific holding, which is why a lender quotes indicative ratios only after reviewing the position rather than off a published rate card. As the share price moves, the ratio moves with it: a falling price lifts the ratio toward the threshold, while a rising price restores headroom. Understanding where your starting ratio sits relative to any maintenance level tells you how much decline the facility can tolerate before action is required. The relationship between price movement and these ratios is explored further in our note on volatility and loan-to-value.
What is a margin call, and how do you avoid one?
A margin call is a demand, in a recourse or margin-style facility, that you restore the loan-to-value ratio to within the agreed level once a price fall has pushed it past the maintenance threshold. You typically satisfy it in one of two ways: by posting additional eligible collateral, or by repaying a portion of the principal — either of which lowers the ratio back into the permitted range. Facilities usually allow a short cure period rather than demanding settlement instantly, though the window is finite and failure to meet the call can lead to the lender realising the collateral. The most reliable way to avoid a call is structural: choosing a conservative opening ratio so the buffer is wide, or selecting a non-recourse profile where no call mechanism exists. Our note on avoiding margin calls sets out the practical options, and the trade-offs between recourse types are discussed under eligibility. Whether a call can arise at all is fixed by the structure, not by market conditions.
How does non-recourse protect you on the downside?
In a non-recourse facility, the lender’s only remedy on default is the pledged collateral itself. If the shares fall below the outstanding loan balance, you are not asked to top up, and you face no margin call; you may elect to surrender the shares and walk away with no further personal liability for the shortfall. The lender absorbs the loss below the agreed level because it priced that risk into the original advance rate — which is why non-recourse facilities generally carry a more conservative loan-to-value and a higher cost than full-recourse equivalents. The protection is real but not free: you are paying, in effect, for an embedded option on the downside. This structure suits holders of concentrated positions who cannot tolerate open-ended liability or the reputational consequences of a forced public sale. Why the structure matters, and when the premium is justified, is set out in our note on why non-recourse matters. Whether it is right for you depends on the holding and your jurisdiction, and independent advice should be taken.
How do holders choose between the two?
The choice turns on a single trade-off: cost against certainty. A full-recourse facility typically offers a higher advance rate and a lower interest cost, because the lender retains a claim against you beyond the collateral — but it exposes you to margin calls and, ultimately, personal liability for any shortfall. A non-recourse facility removes that exposure entirely at the price of a lower advance and a higher rate. Between the two sits limited-recourse, where liability is capped at a defined level rather than eliminated. The right answer depends on how concentrated the position is, how much of your wealth it represents, your tolerance for posting further collateral, and whether a forced sale would carry consequences beyond the financial. A founder or substantial shareholder with disclosure obligations often values certainty over headline advance rate; a borrower with ample outside liquidity may reasonably accept call risk for cheaper funding. The firm quotes indicative ratios only after reviewing the position, and you can begin that conversation through contact. Specifics depend on the holding and jurisdiction, and independent advice should be taken.
Frequently asked.
01What happens if my pledged stock falls below the loan value?
02Can I get a margin call on a non-recourse stock loan?
03How far can a stock fall before I have to act?
04Is a non-recourse stock loan worth the higher cost?
Keep reading.
Are Stock Loans Safe? The Risks Explained
A stock loan is a legitimate institutional tool, but it carries genuine risks — price, custody, counterparty, recourse and currency — that a holder must understand and a well-structured facility is designed to contain.
Read → Risk · April 25, 2022Hedging a concentrated position alongside a loan
Shareholders who borrow against a concentrated equity position carry both financing risk and market risk. Combining a loan with a hedging strategy can address both — but requires careful coordination.
Read →A position to talk through?
Send a confidential enquiry, and a senior principal will reply within one business day.